Why employee churn is lethal to Software
Even as a product manager when I pick up a software to further build it out, certain features need context becasue outright they just feel weird. Only after talking to first generation product manager, it becomes clear why a feature was built the way it is.
Baldur Bjarnason writing about Theory-building and why employee churn is lethal to software companies:
What keeps the software alive are the programmers who have an accurate mental model (theory) of how it is built and works. That mental model can only be learned by having worked on the project while it grew or by working alongside somebody who did, who can help you absorb the theory. Replace enough of the programmers, and their mental models become disconnected from the reality of the code, and the code dies. That dead code can only be replaced by new code that has been ‘grown’ by the current programmers.
You would think documenting your code would work.
Documentation only works up to a point because it can both get out of sync with what the code is doing and because documenting the internals of a complex piece of software is a rare skill. A skill that most developers don’t possess. Most internal documentation only begins to make sense to a developer after they’ve developed an internal mental model of how it all hangs together. Most code documentation becomes useful after you have built the theory in your mind, not before. It operates as a mnemonic for what you already know, not as a tool for learning.
Its a fascinating read. Even as a product manager when I pick up a software to further build it out, certain features just feel weird. One needs to build and understand that mental model (or context). Only after talking to first generation product manager, it becomes clear why a feature was built the way it is.
Constant churn in a software development team, both among the programmers and designers, is absolutely devastating. It is the death knell for a software project. Makes deadlines meaningless. It turns software into a disposable, single-use product like a paper towel. Anything that increases team member churn threatens the very viability of the project and the software it’s creating.
Churn indeed is destructive.